Both compared models, the Audi A6 and Lexus ES, boast a maximum five-star rating in independent Euro NCAP safety tests. When choosing a used car, however, it is crucial to put these prestigious results into the correct context and consider the year the crash tests were physically performed.
Euro NCAP's methodology is constantly evolving and becoming stricter. Today's tests place much greater emphasis on advanced active assistance systems, cyclist detection systems, intersection emergency scenarios, or complex frontal collision simulations with a mobile barrier. Therefore, percentage scores from different years cannot be directly compared. In the case of these two models, however, an ideal situation arises – both vehicles underwent barrier tests in the same year (2018), allowing for a completely fair and direct comparison according to the protocols in force at the time.
Audi A6: Protection with German Precision
The German Audi A6 limousine (current C8 generation) completed a series of crash tests in the autumn of 2018. It earned an excellent 93% for adult occupant protection, confirming the extraordinary rigidity of its construction combining steel and aluminum elements. Child occupant protection was rated at a solid 85%. Regarding vulnerable road users (pedestrians and cyclists), the car achieved a score of 81%, largely thanks to the active hood, which lifts upon detecting an impact to cushion the pedestrian's fall. In the safety assist category, Audi scored 76%, relying as standard on Audi pre sense front technology with obstacle detection and automatic emergency braking.
Lexus ES: A Premium Shield from Japan
The seventh-generation Lexus ES also underwent testing in 2018 and achieved such convincing results that it even took home the Euro NCAP award for the safest large family and hybrid car of the year. Adult protection reached a great 91%, and for child occupants, the car scored an above-average 87%. However, the result in the area of pedestrian and cyclist protection was absolutely phenomenal, where Lexus achieved an unprecedented 90% thanks to the sophisticated Lexus Safety System+ safety package. The car's assistance systems were rated at 77%, pointing to very generous safety equipment even in the base model.
What the Results Mean for the Used Car Market
From the perspective of today's buyer of an approximately four-year-old used car, one formal detail must be mentioned. Euro NCAP ratings are usually valid for exactly six years from the date of the test. This means that the five-star certificates of both these cars from 2018 have formally expired recently, and according to the latest strict standards from 2024, the cars would have to undergo a new assessment. In terms of physical passive safety and the robustness of assistance systems, however, they are still among the best-protected cars in their class on the current used car market, easily averting most common risky situations.
In conclusion, although both limousines represent an equally safe choice in terms of passive protection for adult occupants, the Japanese model comes out slightly ahead in this direct duel. The Lexus ES offers somewhat more convincing results in child protection and absolutely excels in consideration for vulnerable road users. As a result, the ES provides a slightly more comprehensive and modern safety standard.