When evaluating the safety of common modern cars, one often starts by mentioning the five-star rating in Euro NCAP tests. For such results, it is crucial to emphasize the importance of context and the year of testing. Euro NCAP protocols are constantly evolving and becoming stricter – today's standards require advanced frontal crash simulations, cyclist detection, or solutions for crisis scenarios at intersections. Percentage scores from different years cannot be directly compared. In the case of highly exclusive sports cars, such as approximately four-year-old used Maserati MC20s and Porsche 911, the situation is different. Due to their high purchase price and low production volume, these models have never undergone official laboratory crash tests by Euro NCAP.
The Maserati MC20 (produced since 2021) therefore offers no percentage data from Euro NCAP testing facilities. Passenger safety is primarily ensured by the construction itself, led by an exceptionally stiff and lightweight carbon fiber monocoque, which forms an effective survival cell. Regarding active safety, the car is fundamentally focused on a pure driving experience, but customers had the option to purchase a modern driver assistance package. In used cars, this may (but does not have to) include autonomous emergency braking with pedestrian and cyclist detection, blind spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, or traffic sign recognition.
Even the current generation of the Porsche 911 (designation 992, on the market since 2019) has not been tested according to strict Euro NCAP protocols, which is, however, a long-term historical standard for this model. The car's passive safety benefits from an excellently designed rigid body combining high-strength steel and aluminum, complemented by a full set of modern airbags for front passengers. A strong point of Porsche is clearly the availability of active safety features. In addition to the incomparably tuned Porsche Stability Management (PSM) system, the Porsche 911 offers comprehensive protection including optional adaptive cruise control, lane keep assist, or even advanced night vision assist with a thermal camera.
Comparing the level of passive and active protection of both these cars, both meet today's strictest standards. From the perspective of overall usability, however, the Porsche 911 offers a more comprehensive and modern package of active safety systems, which you will appreciate during daily use in normal traffic. In contrast, the Maserati MC20 maintains a purer approach, where trust is placed in the exceptionally strong carbon structure born for motorsport.
Euro NCAP Results Comparison